EDUCATE - Other Reservations
“There is a fundamental desire by the U.S. to address the compelling
and often Third World conditions found in many native communities.
. . . yet, in many parts of Native America, economic and social
conditions resemble the emergency states associated with natural
disasters, which require federal intervention. “ -Senator Ben Nighthorse
Campbell
Health
Housing
Education
Industry
Food Distribution Programs
There are currently 2.1 million American Indians residing in the
United States, about 25% of whom live on reservations. The disparities
confronting these peoples are the most extreme of any ethnic group
in the United States. Not only do American Indians have the highest
rates of poverty (over twice that of all other ethnic groups), but
they also have the highest unemployment and worst rates of disease.
If this is surprising, also consider the following:
The poverty rate increases to 31.2% when addressing American Indians
living on reservations; that is 1 in 3 people (Census Bureau, 2001).
Approximately 90,000 Native families are homeless or under-housed.
(Senate Indian Affairs Committee, 2002)
30% of homes on reservations are overcrowded, compared to 5.7% of
homes of the general U.S. population. (Senate Indian Affairs Committee,
2002)
American Indians are 670 percent more likely to die from alcoholism,
650 percent more likely to die from tuberculosis, 318 percent more
likely to die from diabetes than any other ethnic group (Indian
Health Services, 2002)
In 2004, American Indian schools will spend approximately $3,000
per student, less than half the amount that other public schools
will spend (Bureau of Indian Affairs, 2004)
Over 50% of homes on reservations lack connection to a public sewage
system, compared to 1.2% of the general U.S. population. (Senate
Indian Affairs Committee, 2002)
11% of American Indian homes lack kitchen facilities, compared to
1% national average (Government Accounting Office, 2005)
There is no single cause for these disparities. The geographic remoteness,
lack of economic development, political corruption within the tribal
council, and inadequate federal assistance are all to blame. These
problems are not foreign to us, they are the same conditions that
we here of time and time again in mainstream media, but in relationship
to other areas of the world. Our indigenous peoples are living in
similar, if not the same, conditions as the indigenous peoples of
the developing world.
Knowledge of the abject conditions on American Indian reservations
is muddled by the derisory coverage of gaming and casino revenues
by the mainstream media, amongst other things. As reported in a
recent US News article:
"There's this new stereotype that Indians are rich now, because
of the casinos," Hall says. "But out of the 200 or so tribes that
have casinos, maybe 25 of those are doing pretty good, and that's
stretching it." Some of the poorest tribes, such as the Navajo and
Hopi, have rejected gambling as culturally inappropriate, and many
others are too remote to rake in huge profits.
Health
American Indians have the highest rates of diabetes, AIDS, alcoholism
and tuberculosis amongst all ethnic groups in the United States.
Yet, most American Indians do not have private health insurance
and rely heavily on the Indian Health Services (IHS) for coverage.
Not only is the IHS severly under funded, with 60% less spending
on its beneficiaries than the national average, but the IHS only
allocates approximately $2,000 per American Indian each year. This
is only half of what our federal prisoners receive! Coupled with
this issue are the poor health care facilities available to American
Indians. Health care facilities are typically inadequately supplied,
with treatment and prevention programs that are heavily under funded
and are usually remotely located, requiring individuals to travel
very long distances for services. As a result of these compounding
issues, it is estimated that the health status of American Indians
is 20 to 25 years behind rest of the nation. So, it should be of
no surprise that the life expectancy of American Indians is on average
6 six years less than the national average, and amongst the Lakota
tribe of South Dakota it is as low as 42 for men and 52 for women;
that is a 30 year difference! This is characteristic of a poor developing
nation, not a rich industrialized nation. The mental health amongst
American Indians is equally despairing. Suicide rates amongst adolescents
on the reservations are twice as high as the national average, and
the majority of the suicides involve alcohol. Yet, on reservations
such as Pine Ridge, where alcoholism affects 80% of the population,
there are no treatment facilities.
In order to understand the rapidly deteriorating health of the American
Indians, it is also necessary to address the drastic changes in
nutrition that they have endured over the last 150 years. Traditionally,
native diets were high in protein and low in fat. For centuries,
they feasted on berries, roots, vegetables and wild game, which
provided a balanced, nutritious diet. When the American Indians
were 'placed' on reservations they were stripped of their self-sufficiency.
Instead of continuing to live off the land, they were forced to
eat the commodities provided to them by the federal government.
These foods have traditionally been highly processed and refined,
high in fat and cholesterol, and laden with sugars and salt. This
has resulted in a high incidence of diabetes on the reservations.
In fact, American Indians have the highest rates of Type 2 diabetes
in the world. Access to healthy foods remains very limited, especially
for individuals and families living in isolated areas of the reservation.
Housing
Overcrowding and substandard housing has chronically plagued life
on the reservation. It is not uncommon to have 12-15 people living
in an 800 square foot, two-bedroom home. In addition, large proportions
of the homes are lacking indoor plumbing, sewer service, heating,
and adequate insulation. Many homes are also lacking electricity.
Very few American Indians are homeowners due to limited or no access
to credit and land ownership restrictions. This housing endemic
finally resulted in some presidential attention when then president
Bill Clinton visited the Pine Ridge Reservation in South Dakota
in 1999. While HUD initially received funding to improve housing,
the funding increase was quickly reduced, hindering any substantial
progress from taking place. As a result there is an estimated 200,000
housing units in immediate need amongst American Indian families
living on reservations across the United States.
Education
As a group, Native American students are not afforded educational
opportunities equal to other American students. They regularly confront
dilapidated school facilities, outdated resources such as computers,
cultural differences, and underpaid teachers. Teacher turnover rates
are 700% higher than the national average on some reservations!
The end result in learning is that achievement scores for basic
levels of reading, math, and history are lower amongst American
Indians than any other ethnic group. With little job opportunity,
almost 50% of students drop out of high school. The vocational programs
that do exist are poorly funded. For those students that do persevere
through high school and enter a tribal college, the conditions don't
improve. Tribal colleges receive 60% less federal funding per student
than other public community colleges, and face the same shortages
in technology, educational materials and staff that exists at the
elementary and secondary levels.
Industry
The disparate condition of the impoverished reservations has a strong
connection to the lack of substantial commercial, industrial and
agricultural development, resulting in high rates of unemployment.
Due to geographic remoteness, few industries are willing to build
on reservations. Additionally, the infrastructure, ie. roads, to
support new development are lacking. In order to improve living
conditions, many American Indians move to urban areas, but often
they still find themselves in extremely poor neighborhoods, and
struggle to find suitable employment. For anyone making the transition
from a rural to an urban life, the change can be very challenging,
but American Indians often face the additional challenges of overcoming
a poor educational background, few, if any, industrial skills and
discrimination. As a result they may only be able to fill seasonal
and/or low-paying jobs, often causing them to never escape the poverty
they were fleeing from by leaving the reservation. Many, consequentially
return to the reservation, frustrated and without any money.
Food Distribution Program on Indian Reservations (FDPIR)
This is the only nutrition program designed specifically for American
Indians. The program provides monthly supplemental food packages
weighing between 50 and 70 pounds to low-income households living
on American Indian Reservations. Participation in Food Stamp Programs
amongst American Indians living on reservations tends to be substantially
lower than rest of the low-income families in America. This is caused
by several factors. First of all, the tribal offices on each reservation
are not permitted to administer the food stamp programs. This entails
residents leaving the reservation to visit federal offices that
may be several hours away from their home. Additionally, the grocery
stores located on the reservation tend to be much more expensive,
which drastically limits the amount people can stretch their benefits
or may not even accept the food stamps. Food stamps may also be
cut off when participants work even a minimum wage job, which works
as a disincentive for finding employment. Forced to choose between
either food stamps or the commodities provided through FDPIR (people
are not allowed to participate in both), most choose the commodities.
As many as six out of 10 households rely on FDPIR as their primary
or only source of food.